We are back to the geopolitical drawing board with the Russians having a stronger position in every aspect except PR.
XContact us: @worldanalyticspress_bot
When one lives in Russia and speaks the language well it is easy to detect dissonance when it comes to news about the country and its foreign policy. Obviously, the West says Russia is either losing the war or suffering a pyrrhic victory, whereas the Russian side portrays itself as winning at the proper or perhaps slightly-too-slow-but-understandable pace. This dual reality is something we all get used to but at times it can be very dangerous or at the very least quite loud and there is one story of this nature that is screaming loudly across all social media only on the Western side.
From the New York Times to Mario Nawfal everyone and their cousin in the English-speaking world is discussing the ‘unreasonable’ and ‘insane’ demand by the Russians that NATO should return to its 1997 borders. Of course, the media has terrible long-term memory when that status suits their interests and they consciously forget to mention that the Russians already provided this option to Biden’s team in December of 2021. That is to say, this return to 1997 was the Russian starting negotiating point that was designed to avoid the war in Ukraine entirely. Of course, as history will note, every single one of the Russians’ demands were rejected perhaps without even being seriously read or considered. The Kremlin got a unilateral immediate “no” from the global hegemon and thus war would come to Ukraine within a month and a half from that moment. All hope was lost to settle European security without gunshots for Putin and the Security Council.


Image above: All sorts of odd channels are going nuts over Russia supposedly ‘out of nowhere’ demanding for a return to 1997 NATO borders, just like they did already in 2021.
The Ministry of Foreign of Affairs of the Russian Federation in January, 2022 publicly answered media questions on the idea of returning to the NATO borders of 1997 (henceforth “Offer 1997”) in written form and these statements was published by Izvestia:
“The one of the pillars of our initiatives that you mentioned is deliberately formulated very clearly and does not allow for any double interpretations. We are talking about the withdrawal of foreign forces, equipment and weapons and other steps to return to the configuration as of 1997 on the territory of countries that were not members of NATO on that date. These include Bulgaria and Romania,”
The 21st century seems to be filled with dark political ironies and one of the biggest ones is that after all these years of war, and potentially over a million dead, the negotiating position of the Russian side has not changed. They still want to redraw European security architecture to suit both NATO and Russia. The only thing that has changed, is that Europe has become a broken pauper, the paper tiger of democracy clearly has no longer has any stripes in front of the entire world. Russia’s real economy, real reforms, and real war machine reflect their motto “Strength is in Truth”, that is to say, that narrative weaving cannot save Europe from the upcoming loss, massive debt, and other glowing internal political failures, the only question is how bad and humiliating this all shall be.
Since Russia seems to only be getting stronger and Europe weaker, the idea floated to Team Biden which was laughed at, may actually become a reality or truly be the starting point for negotiations as the war winds down and the last Ukrainian gets his turn at bat.

Image above: Geopolitics fans love drawing maps than LGBT activists love hair dye.
What do the Russians want?
If there is anything that geopolitical wonks like doing, it is drawing up all sorts of maps and fantasy scenarios in their minds. I am often sent messages with concepts that are both interesting, impractical, and most often insane, from all over the world. When one lives in a comfortable academic environment it is easy to dream up all sorts of geopolitical visions: Panslavism 2.0, a Russian-Japanese alliance against America, A Moscow-based Holy Roman Empire that encompasses all the Orthodox nations, etc. This is all fun ‘food for thought’ and great video game scenarios, but the realities of what the Russian side wants in terms of security are quite clear; No NATO on their borders and No ‘anti-Russia’ states that exist just to throw their population as kamikaze troops against the Kremlin’s walls. This is what they want in terms of European security architecture, but will they be able to get it even as Kiev burns in darkness is another question entirely.
If Offer 1997 is the maximalist position of the Russians, I would say their minimalist position would be as follows in terms of territory:
- The entire Donbass as defined by the Russian constitution
Numerous Russian leaders have repeatedly made it clear that in connection with the constitutional referendum of 2020, Russia cannot lawfully decrease in size. There is no legal mechanism to chop up the Donbass into politically expedient chunks. Further , Russia has democracy than you think, and doing such a cowardly and treacherous move would have massive consequences for the Kremlin and the future of Russia. Putin and the Security Council understand this quite well.
- A buffer zone to protect Bryansk and Kursk which would essentially absorb at least the Harkov (Kharkov/Kharkiv) and Sumy Regions of 1991 Ukraine
From rumor, to idea, to stated objective; as revenge for the attacks on Kursk, Belgorod and Bryansk, Putin has made it clear that some sort of buffer zone has to be created in the north of present day Ukraine. Some say this will be 30km wide, and some say 100km, but regardless, the Russians will need to take a lot of the territories listed above if not all of them to establish this buffer zone. The distance from Belgorod to Harkov is 70km, and from Kursk to Sumy is 130km for example.
- A border that makes contact with Transniestria/Moldova which would demand the taking of Odessa in order to avert the next war
President Sandu is just Zelensky in a skirt and Moldova is another anti-Russian powder keg waiting to blow that has been manufactured by the same evil forces that want to break Russia. From the Kremlin’s viewpoint having a long-term peace means that there must be access to Moldova so that way any Maidan-like treatment of the locals can be responded to with haste. Moldova if left ‘behind enemy lines’ could be used like a hostage against Moscow for years to come. Further , the Russian troops in Transniestria were there legally by UN resolution and Putin likes to keep things consistent when it comes to international law.
- Part of Kiev proper
Kiev is like Jerusalem or Mecca; a city of great spiritual importance, but for the Russians. It is the birthplace of their civilization as well as the location where they were all Christened. This may sound like insane reasoning, but few intellectuals or thinking patriots would pass at the chance to technically take back at least some of this sacred ground, for as time goes on such a chance my never blow bye in the wind again.
Optional but vital demands are still relevant
These things that are listed above are the absolute minimum for the Russian population and elite to consider that they ‘won the war’ and that their security is not in immediate jeopardy. But the winning side is often not happy with the bare minimum. The Kremlin will want peperoni on its security pizza for sure. Here are some things they would like, but won’t go to nuclear war over yet:
- No Borders with NATO at all
Belarus having a border with Poland is fine. Finland came into NATO recently and has had their economy get crushed by sanctions blowback, thus they can easily just leave. Depending how Ukraine winds up, Russia can create neutral borders to the south, but the big sticking point would be the Baltics. The “Chihuahuas” have been living off Western investment for Russophobia like geopolitical OnlyFans models for their entire post Cold War history.
For the sake of three tiny, poor, Eastern European nations that Brits and Americans cannot spell, Washington will not risk a nuclear WWIII. Something in the Baltics will have to change, however their fragility means they cannot change or else they will just be sucked back into Russia’s orbit. Moscow can offer them not only cultural and linguistic freedom, but cheap energy, jobs, and for the Ministry of Internal Affairs to boot out all the EU mystery migrants by force.
Although I stated above that the Kremlin wants absolutely no NATO on its borders, I think they will not push hard to remove Poland and Romania, and may not even really try that sternly for Finland. The Baltics, Moldova + Ukraine are the real burning areas. Also, the Russian citizenry is not that concerned over the destiny of Romania’s military future. Russians volunteered with their lives to ‘save the Donbass’ not alter Finland’s alliances.
- Arms Control of some sort
It is hard to say exactly what kind of arms control is desirable, but having it worked out and followed would certainly put all sides at ease especially the Kremlin, but again, this is not 100% critical at this moment and not worth nuclear war over.
In summation
The important thing to note is that everything is coming full circle, the idea to redraw European security was already issued before the war to avoid it. Now we are back to the geopolitical drawing board with the Russians having a stronger position in every aspect except PR. Be it Offer 1997 in full or something much reduced, the Kremlin must achieve the minimum goals stated above by me in order to win both at home spiritually and factually in terms of their security. But of course, they would much prefer to have NATO as far away as possible with zero border contact and new arms control deals that will be obeyed by both Democrats and Republicans for generations to come.

